← Every view

Vlada · Research · 2026-08-05 · observed

One hospital. One surgery. Ten different prices.

One hospital · one operation · what each plan pays

Knee surgery, the surgeon's part of the bill
Hospital for Special Surgery, New YorkValue
UnitedHealthcareEmployer plan3,752.15
Anthem NYEmployer plan3,332.31
AetnaEmployer plan3,201.84
NYSHIPState employee plan3,022.87
CignaEmployer plan2,726.6
EmblemHealthEmployer plan2,389.07
UnitedHealthcareMedicare Advantage1,365.18
FidelisLow-cost state plan1,228.67
FidelisMedicaid1,023.89
MetroPlusMedicaid739.53

Negotiated dollar rate · USD · file version 2026-05 · CPT 29867, facility-rate rows, professional billing class · Hospital price transparency file, CCN 330270, as published · 10 rows

The posted figure

Read with

  • One hospital. This is the shape of the thing, not a national finding.
  • Professional billing class: the surgeon's fee for the procedure, not the whole episode and not the facility DRG.
  • Office-rate rows excluded as a different site of service.
  • The ladder contains Medicare Advantage and Medicaid managed care, not traditional Medicare, so it cannot support a claim about a multiple of the Medicare rate.
  • payer_name in the source table is free text, not canonical.

Ask about this view

3 days free · then $99 a month
The post